The chaos here isn't the gift, it's the signal. You're not buying a present, you're making an argument about how you see this person, and they'll read it whether you meant to or not. In India, first dates still happen with social visibility: the friend who knows, the WhatsApp location shared just in case. The gift has to pass that audience too. Go too expensive and it reads as pressure. Go nothing and you're just another profile they swiped right on.
Something edible, consumable, or sensory and small is your safest bet. A premium chocolate box (single-serve, nicely packaged), artisanal coffee from a small-batch Indian roaster, or a soy wax candle in a mini jar: these share one quality. They disappear. No 'what do I do with this now' moment, no shelf evidence of a date that may or may not go anywhere. The person gets to enjoy it soon, and you get credit for paying attention without making it a whole production. Stay under ₹800 and you're in the right zone.
Avoid anything with a future built into it: a book you think they'll love, a journal, anything personalized. This seems thoughtful but what it actually says is 'I've imagined us three months from now.' Flowers are high-risk in Indian urban dating. They're visible, they communicate publicly, and on a first date that's a lot of theatre for two people who haven't even ordered yet. Wait until you're actually seeing each other before you buy something they can't quietly put away.